- Gym World
- Posts
- Convert Gym Leads: How to Fix the 75% That Never Book
Convert Gym Leads: How to Fix the 75% That Never Book
Data from 1,000+ Kilo gyms shows where leads fall out of the funnel and what the best gyms do about it
What's up, Gym World?
Every gym owner I talk to says the same thing: "I just need more leads." Then I look at their pipeline, and most of the leads they already have never turn into a conversation.
This week on Run a Profitable Gym, I sat down with Kilo CEO Kaleda Connell to review data from over 1,000 Kilo gyms used in the Two-Brain Business State of the Industry Report.
The average gym gets about 32 leads a month, and only about one in four books an appointment. That means roughly three out of four leads never get a conversation.
If you want to convert gym leads at a higher rate, the data shows where to look first. We went through the funnel step by step, starting with the gyms at the top of each list.
What the Gyms With the Most Leads Do
We started with three gyms that get 100 to 250 leads a month. They get there in different ways.
Unleash'd Strength: Joe Strada's gym gets around 250 leads a month, and more than 3,000 over the last 12 months. He runs ads, hosts events, and posts quirky content, but he doesn't have a giant following. He recently posted that a campaign was getting $4 leads. Joe's gym is an access gym with a low-cost membership alongside personal training, so there's less friction than at a personal training or small-group gym.

MVMT Strength: Isaac Morgado, who runs MVMT Strength in London, Ontario, built a 50,000-follower TikTok account that didn't turn into much revenue. When his team traced the funnel, they found their gym podcast was the real moneymaker, so they built their content cycle around it and repeated what worked.

Gas Station Fitness: This UK gym gets 100+ leads a month, and they run a well-structured ad set on repeat and call new leads quickly.

The common thread is a strong organic presence. Meta's 2025 Andromeda update favors accounts that also publish organic content, so ads tend to perform better when paired with strong organic content.
Convert Gym Leads Into Booked Appointments
Speak to one client avatar
Nora Matthew of Her Strength Studio, a women-only small group gym in Latham, New York, has a 62% set rate. She doesn't run many ads or have a big following, and she gets hundreds of leads a year, not thousands. She still books more people than some gyms with far more leads.

Her website used to show young people, and her market skews older. Someone called to ask whether she really helps women her age, because the site didn't show anyone like her. She updated the site, moved to a more visible location, and booked more appointments.
Kaleda's exercise for finding your avatar: list the five to ten people who pay you the most and the five to ten who are the most fun to work with, then look at what they have in common.
💬 Nora doubled her clientele in two years after moving to a main street location and updating her website. Read her full story here.
Set price expectations before the appointment
Stan Skolfield of Skolfield Sports Performance has a 39% booking rate, which is above average. He calls leads from his gym and tells them the price and expectations before they book. His onboarding program costs $1,500 upfront, and he sells to the parents, so setting expectations early means people come in ready to buy.

Kaleda recommends posting pricing on your website, but some owners are uncomfortable with that; a range or a starting price over the phone works too. At Two-Brain, we recommend hiding pricing in two cases: you sell something high-ticket and more than 70% of people would gasp, or your offer is too confusing to explain in two or three bullet points.
💬 Stan breaks down his full system in A $1,500 offer that converts 95% of athletes.
Call fast and call every day
Gas Station's Dai Palmer blocks out time every day to call leads, with a system for reminders and speed-to-lead. Gas Station relies heavily on paid ads, which typically drive lower set rates, so appearing on this list says a lot about their follow-up.
Send ad traffic to landing pages
I ran a training with Lisa and Dai Palmer where we put their data into Claude along with their Facebook Ads Manager, so we could see every step of the funnel. They run lead ads to a lead form and to a landing page. Leads from the form are six times cheaper. But only 5% of form leads book an appointment, compared with 40% of landing page leads.
That's the case for tracking the full funnel instead of cost per lead. If you only watch cost per lead, you're driving without a map. Kaleda says Gym Lead Machine and Kilo both have a Claude MCP connection, so owners can pull funnel numbers into an AI tool themselves.
Get Booked Leads to Show Up
Show rate is the hardest number to track. Gym Lead Machine moves leads through your pipeline automatically until the appointment, but the owner has to mark whether the person showed up. About half of appointments never get updated, so the data can be messy.
The Two-Brain benchmark is above 70%, and the best gyms in Kilo are at 80% or higher. Here's what we covered:
Send a reminder text at 8 p.m. the night before. The team at Gas Station found that time slot works because people are on the couch planning their next day.
Keep the booking window tight. The best gyms book about 48 hours out, and some go to 72.
Personalize reminders. Use the person's first name or record a quick 10 or 30 second video. With 8 to 10 appointments a month, that's two to three videos a week.
Say when a message is automated. Clark Hibbs of Yellow Rose Fitness adds that a person will reply if they respond.
Do a short pre-call. Nora does a 15-minute call to build rapport and address objections early.
Close the Appointments You Book
About 45 to 50% of appointments close, or one in every two. Kaleda aims for about 70%, and some Kilo gyms reach 80-85%.
The gyms at the top of this list also appear on the earlier lists. They show who they serve, connect with their audience, call leads, and care whether people show up.
In the appointment, Kaleda's advice is to listen, add value, show a clear plan from where the person is to where they want to be, and then ask for the money.
Keep the Members You Close
Retention matters because each member who leaves means finding three to four leads to replace them.
The average member stays about 20 months. Clark Hibbs keeps members for 30 to 32 months while charging almost double what most gyms charge.
His 90-day onboarding system is high-touch.
Automations go to him or his staff, not the client. The team reviews a member's last few weeks of workouts and sends a personal note. Clark believes that if he keeps people through the first 90 days, they stick around.
TL;DR
Before you spend more on leads, take a look at the ones you already have. The average gym in this dataset gets about 32 leads a month, but only one in four books an appointment.
Here’s where to focus:
Follow up with the leads already in your pipeline. Call new leads quickly and block out time for follow-up every day.
Make it clear who your gym is for. Show the people you help, and use consistent content to build trust before they reach out.
Set expectations before people book. Explain your offer and give prospects a clear idea of the price.
Track booked appointments, not just cheap leads. A low cost per lead means little if nobody books.
Give people a reason to show up. Book within about 48 hours, send a reminder the night before, and make the follow-up personal.
Keep delivering after the sale. Put real effort into the first 90 days so the members you worked to win have a reason to stay.
More leads won’t fix a leaky funnel. Start by helping more of the people already interested take the next step.
To see where your gym stacks up, grab the free State of the Industry Report at twobrainbusiness.com/data.
For the full conversation, watch the episode on YouTube.
until next week,
j